A different take on forgiveness

Lynne McTaggart

Amid all the near daily revelations about sexual predators, charges of racism deep political divisions that exists among political parties in America and Britain, I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the concept of forgiveness.

Not in the sense of ‘turn-the-other-cheek’ style forgiveness, but as an act of deep truth-telling to heal deep differences and transgressions and establish a reconciliation.
As co-director of the Social Healing Project my dear friend James O’Dea, former director of the Washington, D. C. office of Amnesty International, has spent many years smoothing the way for warring sides to reconcile and forgive.
For ten years he and Dr. Judith Thompson co-hosted “compassion and social healing” dialogues, in which members of highly divided social and political groups — Republican and loyalist Northern Irish, Turkish and Greek Cypriots, Israelis and Palestinians — met in an attempt to heal shared wounds.
In the dialogues, O’Dea and Thompson moved the emphasis away from who is right and who is wrong, and toward who is wounded and how to heal. The aim was to help each party to recognize the other’s pain or shame and, in so doing, to liberate each other from hurt and guilt.
Mutual liberation
Their method draws upon the work of theologian Geiko Müller-Fahrenholz and his book The Art of Forgiveness.  Born in 1940, Müller-Fahrenholz was too young to have any memory of the Third Reich or Hitler, but like so many post-war Germans, he grew up haunted by Germany’s terrible legacy and so began to consider forgiveness from the perspective of both victim and perpetrator.
Forgiveness can never replace justice, he realized, but it can move us beyond it. In our present culture, which largely deals with transgression by punishment and imprisonment, both victim and perpetrator remain in bondage. The victim’s dignity and personhood (or goods) are not restored, and the perpetrator never fully truly comes to grips with what he has done.
An act of forgiveness, on the other hand, as philosopher Hannah Arendt once wrote, is a “constant mutual release.” Both victim and perpetrator learn to recognize each other’s pain or shame, and mutually liberate each other from hurt and guilt.
For the perpetrator, full disclosure is, as Müller-Fahrenholz writes, is an act of disarmament — a willingness to finally confront the truth about oneself. It shines light on the unspeakable aspects of a wrongdoing, which paves the way for atonement. The humanity of the other laid bare seems to spark responsibility in the listener and creates a catharsis and a way of moving forward.
O’Dea discovered the power of deep truthfulness to bridge the greatest of breaches during a social-healing meeting that included Mary Rothchild, the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, and Gottfried Leich, who had been a member of the Hitler Youth Movement during the Third Reich in Germany.
Leich had been intensely fearful of revealing his history and facing his involvement in the Nazi movement, particularly in front of someone who was a Jew and the daughter of a Holocaust survivor. He had dreaded this encounter more than any in his life.
Early in the dialogue, Rothchild turned to Leich and said, “There are many people in my extended family who were killed in the Holocaust. What was your role in it?”
Leich admitted that he had beaten up people and set buildings alight on Kristallnacht, the Kristallnacht in 1938, when Nazi storm troopers smashed thousands of Jewish homes, shops and synagogues. “But I was only 16,” he added.
Rothchild wasn’t satisfied. “So, if you had been 10 years older, would you have taken my relatives to the gas chamber?”
Leich took a very long time to answer and looked down at the floor. “I just don’t know,” he said finally.
Rothchild was utterly transformed by his answer. She had not expected such stark honesty from a person who represented the very archetype of otherness to her. With Leich’s admission, they both entered a completely new territory of truth: yes, he was saying, I could have been a mass murderer.
Leich became overwhelmed with self-loathing. He broke down and cried. “I am a grandfather and my grandchildren are the grandchildren of the Nazis. I am in the abyss, the dungeon of history. I always will be connected with this.”
His complete candor had released something inside of Rothchild, an emotional compensation she didn’t know she had been seeking. She stood up, walked over to him and took his hand. “Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,” she whispered to him, “I will fear no evil for thou are with me.”
The heart connects again
Thompson and O’Dea both felt the space between Rothchild and Leich suffused with what felt like a divinely animated presence. For Leich, the experience was a revelation.
Surrendering his fear and facing his past truthfully had created a miracle; Rothchild, he said, had thrown a “bridge across the abyss” and invited him to meet her on it.
Such is the power of deep disclosure or genuine confession that both sides are forever changed by the encounter. When the humanity of both parties shines through during forgiveness, a plan of restitution and new options for the future often simply present themselves.
This moment of connecting to the other’s pain is the transcendent aspect of any relationship, writes Müller-Fahrenholz, offering “a spark of courage to open up, that moment of daring and trusting which causes the heart to jump over the fence.” Ultimately it is this sudden merging that overcomes “the dividing walls” between us.
Seen through this perspective, a disagreement or wrongdoing is an interrupted connection, and forgiveness and restitution a re-establishment of the connection. Transgression is, as Müller-Fahrenholz puts it, a “sin against the whole” and deep truth an end to the “war of the world with itself.”

Facebook Comments

We embed Facebook Comments plugin to allow you to leave comment at our website using your Facebook account. This plugin may collect your IP address, your web browser User Agent, store and retrieve cookies on your browser, embed additional tracking, and monitor your interaction with the commenting interface, including correlating your Facebook account with whatever action you take within the interface (such as “liking” someone’s comment, replying to other comments), if you are logged into Facebook. For more information about how this data may be used, please see Facebook’s data privacy policy: https://www.facebook.com/about/privacy/update

Lynne McTaggart

Lynne McTaggart is an award-winning journalist and the author of seven books, including the worldwide international bestsellers The Power of Eight, The Field, The Intention Experiment and The Bond, all considered seminal books of the New Science and now translated into some 30 languages.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

966 comments on “A different take on forgiveness”

  1. Thank you for this Lynne! An essential aspect of my work with clients is resolving forgiveness at conscious and subconscious levels. Finally being able to perceive our own humanity in the other person is always a profoundly healing event, and this piece and your Masterclass have offered me another valuable angle of approach.

  2. Thank you Lynne, for this beautiful exploration of the power of forgiveness. I believe that forgiveness holds the key to all healing - physical, emotional, and spiritual - including the healing of our mother, the earth. When humanity discovers the art of connecting with every "thing" through love, when we can experience the harm we do to "the environment" as a harm to a living being which is simultaneously a harm to ourselves, the wounds that today may seem impossibly irreversible can be healed. This is my belief. I can't say if or how this would happen on the scale it needs to happen; I can only begin with myself, and articles like this help to remind and motivate me.

  3. I think this shows that forgiveness works if the perpetrator admits and is sorry for their guilt. I don't think blind forgiveness works, where the perpetrator shows no remorse.

  4. We do know this...just sometimes we need to remember the truth we carry. When we remember to love our sacred selves above all else then we will want to be truly free. Forgiveness is only about setting our precious selves free. So remember your divine being and love yourself as is intended.

  5. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]medication from mexico pharmacy[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  6. buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicanph.com/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy

  7. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy

  8. http://mexicanph.shop/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
    reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  9. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://mexicanph.com/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy

  10. buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicanph.shop/#]pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  11. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  12. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  13. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]mexican drugstore online[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  14. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies

  15. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=http://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican pharmacy

  16. reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican drugstore online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  17. mexican pharmacy [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican drugstore online[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  18. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=http://mexicanph.com/#]best online pharmacies in mexico[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies

  19. generic ivermectin for humans [url=https://stromectol.fun/#]ivermectin cost uk[/url] ivermectin 5

  20. ivermectin 3 mg dose [url=http://stromectol.fun/#]stromectol 0.5 mg[/url] ivermectin nz

  21. п»їcipro generic [url=http://cipro.guru/#]buy cipro online without prescription[/url] buy cipro

  22. ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price [url=https://cipro.guru/#]cipro[/url] buy cipro online

  23. buy cytotec in usa [url=http://cytotec24.shop/#]Cytotec 200mcg price[/url] buy misoprostol over the counter

  24. cipro pharmacy [url=http://cipro.guru/#]purchase cipro[/url] ciprofloxacin order online

  25. tamoxifen 20 mg tablet [url=https://nolvadex.guru/#]nolvadex for sale amazon[/url] tamoxifen lawsuit

  26. tamoxifen vs clomid [url=http://nolvadex.guru/#]tamoxifen rash[/url] tamoxifen and weight loss

  27. mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=https://mexicanpharm24.com/#]order online from a Mexican pharmacy[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico mexicanpharm.shop

  28. canadapharmacyonline com [url=http://canadianpharmlk.shop/#]Canada pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy price checker canadianpharm.store

  29. buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicanpharm24.shop/#]Mexico pharmacy online[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies mexicanpharm.shop

  30. prednisone 10 mg tablet [url=http://prednisonest.pro/#]prednisone 10mg buy online[/url] prednisone daily use

  31. how to get cheap clomid tablets [url=http://clomidst.pro/#]order clomid prices[/url] cost generic clomid pill

  32. amoxicillin 500 mg price [url=http://amoxilst.pro/#]amoxicillin 500 mg brand name[/url] order amoxicillin online

  33. ed online pharmacy [url=http://edpills.guru/#]ed online pharmacy[/url] ed meds cheap

  34. online pharmacy no prescription [url=https://onlinepharmacy.cheap/#]Cheapest online pharmacy[/url] international pharmacy no prescription

  35. indian pharmacies safe [url=http://indianpharm.shop/#]india pharmacy[/url] indianpharmacy com

  36. canadian pharmacy online [url=http://canadianpharm.guru/#] best canadian online pharmacy[/url] canada drugs online reviews

  37. pharmacies without prescriptions [url=http://pharmacynoprescription.pro/#]online canadian pharmacy no prescription[/url] online prescription canada

  38. certified canadian international pharmacy [url=https://canadianpharm.guru/#] canadian neighbor pharmacy[/url] medication canadian pharmacy

  39. best india pharmacy [url=https://indianpharm.shop/#]world pharmacy india[/url] indianpharmacy com

  40. canadian pharmacy 24 com [url=http://canadianpharm.guru/#] legit canadian pharmacy online[/url] ed meds online canada

  41. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/#]mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies

  42. Online medicine home delivery [url=http://indianpharmacy.icu/#]indian pharmacy[/url] india pharmacy

  43. indian pharmacy online [url=http://indianpharmacy.icu/#]indian pharmacy paypal[/url] indian pharmacy

  44. canada drugs online review [url=https://canadianpharmacy24.store/#]pharmacies in canada that ship to the us[/url] canadian pharmacy 24 com

  45. mexican drugstore online [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/#]Mexican Pharmacy Online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  46. canadadrugpharmacy com [url=http://canadianpharmacy24.store/#]Large Selection of Medications[/url] canadian pharmacy uk delivery

  47. pharmacy rx world canada [url=http://canadianpharmacy24.store/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] maple leaf pharmacy in canada

  48. canadian pharmacy in canada [url=http://canadianpharmacy24.store/#]pills now even cheaper[/url] canadian pharmacy sarasota

  49. how to get generic clomid price [url=https://clomidall.com/#]cost generic clomid without insurance[/url] can i buy clomid for sale

  50. can i get generic clomid [url=http://clomidall.shop/#]can i order cheap clomid tablets[/url] get cheap clomid for sale

  51. prednisone tablet 100 mg [url=http://prednisoneall.shop/#]prednisone in mexico[/url] prednisone 80 mg daily

  52. prednisone buy canada [url=http://prednisoneall.shop/#]buy prednisone without prescription paypal[/url] cost of prednisone 5mg tablets

  53. generic sildenafil [url=https://sildenafiliq.xyz/#]best price on viagra[/url] п»їBuy generic 100mg Viagra online

  54. Cialis 20mg price in USA [url=https://tadalafiliq.com/#]cialis without a doctor prescription[/url] cialis for sale

  55. over the counter sildenafil [url=https://sildenafiliq.xyz/#]generic ed pills[/url] sildenafil over the counter

  56. viagra canada [url=https://sildenafiliq.com/#]best price for viagra 100mg[/url] viagra without prescription

  57. best price for viagra 100mg [url=http://sildenafiliq.com/#]sildenafil iq[/url] Generic Viagra online

  58. onlinecanadianpharmacy [url=https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/#]canadianpharmacymeds[/url] canada pharmacy reviews

  59. northern pharmacy canada [url=https://canadianpharmgrx.com/#]CIPA approved pharmacies[/url] online canadian drugstore

  60. reputable canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/#]Canadian pharmacy prices[/url] reliable canadian pharmacy reviews

  61. online pharmacy india [url=http://indianpharmgrx.shop/#]Generic Medicine India to USA[/url] best india pharmacy

  62. india online pharmacy [url=http://indianpharmgrx.com/#]Healthcare and medicines from India[/url] india pharmacy mail order

  63. my canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/#]My Canadian pharmacy[/url] vipps canadian pharmacy

  64. reputable canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadianpharmgrx.xyz/#]Cheapest drug prices Canada[/url] canadian pharmacy meds

  65. п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india [url=http://indianpharmgrx.com/#]indian pharmacy[/url] online shopping pharmacy india

  66. canadianpharmacymeds [url=http://canadianpharmgrx.com/#]Certified Canadian pharmacies[/url] canadian pharmacy mall

  67. buy cipro online canada [url=https://ciprofloxacin.guru/#]cipro for sale[/url] antibiotics cipro

  68. doxycycline monohydrate [url=https://doxycyclinest.pro/#]buy doxycycline cheap[/url] buy doxycycline monohydrate

  69. cipro online no prescription in the usa [url=http://ciprofloxacin.guru/#]buy cipro online canada[/url] buy ciprofloxacin

  70. diflucan over the counter nz [url=https://diflucan.icu/#]diflucan men[/url] diflucan cost uk

  71. diflucan 200mg tab [url=https://diflucan.icu/#]diflucan 100 mg tablet[/url] buying diflucan over the counter

  72. Abortion pills online [url=http://misoprostol.top/#]cytotec buy online usa[/url] purchase cytotec

  73. tamoxifen citrate [url=https://nolvadex.icu/#]tamoxifen lawsuit[/url] does tamoxifen cause bone loss

  74. stromectol otc [url=http://stromectola.top/#]stromectol order[/url] ivermectin lotion for lice

  75. amoxicillin price without insurance [url=https://amoxicillina.top/#]amoxicillin 500mg buy online uk[/url] amoxicillin without prescription

  76. zithromax 250mg [url=https://azithromycina.pro/#]zithromax for sale 500 mg[/url] zithromax cost uk

  77. online canadian pharmacy no prescription [url=https://medicationnoprescription.pro/#]ordering prescription drugs from canada[/url] canadian and international prescription service

  78. prescription drugs from canada [url=https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/#]canadian pharmacy no prescription needed[/url] cheapest pharmacy to get prescriptions filled

  79. online erectile dysfunction pills [url=http://edpill.top/#]cheapest erectile dysfunction pills[/url] ed medicines

  80. game c? b?c online uy tin [url=http://casinvietnam.shop/#]game c? b?c online uy tin[/url] danh bai tr?c tuy?n

  81. top online pharmacy india [url=http://indiaph24.store/#]indian pharmacy[/url] india online pharmacy

  82. lisinopril 40 mg generic [url=https://lisinopril.network/#]lisinopril 10 mg 12.5mg[/url] lisinopril 40mg

  83. ciprofloxacin over the counter [url=http://ciprofloxacin.tech/#]cipro[/url] cipro ciprofloxacin

  84. cheap propecia for sale [url=https://finasteride.store/#]buying cheap propecia prices[/url] cost generic propecia without dr prescription

  85. buy cytotec in usa [url=http://cytotec.club/#]buy misoprostol over the counter[/url] buy cytotec pills online cheap

  86. propecia without insurance [url=https://finasteride.store/#]buying cheap propecia prices[/url] order generic propecia pill

  87. order propecia without dr prescription [url=https://finasteride.store/#]cheap propecia without prescription[/url] buying cheap propecia without prescription

  88. cipro [url=https://ciprofloxacin.tech/#]buy cipro online without prescription[/url] where can i buy cipro online

  89. lisinopril 50 mg price [url=http://lisinopril.network/#]lisinopril otc[/url] lisinopril medication generic

  90. what is tamoxifen used for [url=http://nolvadex.life/#]nolvadex d[/url] tamoxifen and osteoporosis

  91. lisinopril tabs 20mg [url=https://lisinopril.network/#]lipinpril[/url] lisinopril 10 mg tablet cost

  92. nolvadex during cycle [url=https://nolvadex.life/#]nolvadex estrogen blocker[/url] does tamoxifen cause joint pain

  93. cost of cheap propecia online [url=http://finasteride.store/#]cost propecia tablets[/url] generic propecia prices

  94. lisinopril 20 mg for sale [url=https://lisinopril.network/#]prinivil 5 mg[/url] prinivil drug cost

  95. buy ciprofloxacin over the counter [url=https://ciprofloxacin.tech/#]ciprofloxacin generic[/url] cipro online no prescription in the usa

  96. propecia rx [url=http://finasteride.store/#]generic propecia[/url] cost of cheap propecia tablets

  97. cipro pharmacy [url=http://ciprofloxacin.tech/#]cipro 500mg best prices[/url] buy cipro online canada

  98. lisinopril brand name australia [url=http://lisinopril.network/#]lisinopril 10 mg[/url] zestril tab 10mg

  99. buy cytotec online fast delivery [url=https://cytotec.club/#]cytotec buy online usa[/url] buy cytotec pills

  100. Cialis over the counter [url=http://cialist.pro/#]cialis for sale[/url] Buy Tadalafil 10mg

  101. order cenforce [url=https://cenforce.pro/#]Cenforce 100mg tablets for sale[/url] order cenforce

  102. Cialis 20mg price in USA [url=https://cialist.pro/#]buy cialis online[/url] Cialis over the counter

  103. Purchase Cenforce Online [url=https://cenforce.pro/#]Cenforce 150 mg online[/url] cenforce.pro

  104. Buy Tadalafil 10mg [url=http://cialist.pro/#]Generic Tadalafil 20mg price[/url] Buy Tadalafil 10mg

  105. Generic Tadalafil 20mg price [url=https://cialist.pro/#]Generic Tadalafil 20mg price[/url] Buy Cialis online

  106. Cheap Levitra online [url=http://levitrav.store/#]buy Levitra over the counter[/url] Buy Vardenafil online

  107. Cheap generic Viagra online [url=http://viagras.online/#]Buy generic 100mg Viagra online[/url] Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg

  108. legit canadian pharmacy [url=https://pharmcanada.shop/#]reputable canadian pharmacy[/url] adderall canadian pharmacy

  109. canadian pharmacy no prescription [url=https://pharmworld.store/#]overseas pharmacy no prescription[/url] legit non prescription pharmacies

  110. canada prescription drugs online [url=http://pharmnoprescription.icu/#]no prescription online pharmacies[/url] discount prescription drugs canada

  111. indianpharmacy com [url=http://pharmindia.online/#]buy prescription drugs from india[/url] buy medicines online in india

  112. mexican rx online [url=https://pharmmexico.online/#]buying prescription drugs in mexico online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  113. pharmacy coupons [url=https://pharmworld.store/#]cheapest pharmacy[/url] cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions

  114. canadian pharmacy without a prescription [url=http://pharmnoprescription.icu/#]mexican prescription drugs online[/url] buy prescription drugs online without

  115. top 10 online pharmacy in india [url=https://pharmindia.online/#]Online medicine order[/url] buy prescription drugs from india

  116. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://pharmmexico.online/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico

  117. canadian pharmacy no prescription [url=http://pharmnoprescription.icu/#]buy prescription drugs online without doctor[/url] non prescription online pharmacy india

  118. order neurontin over the counter [url=http://gabapentinneurontin.pro/#]neurontin prescription medication[/url] neurontin 4 mg

  119. where can i purchase zithromax online [url=https://zithromaxa.store/#]where can i buy zithromax capsules[/url] zithromax antibiotic without prescription

  120. purchase amoxicillin 500 mg [url=http://amoxila.pro/#]amoxicillin for sale online[/url] amoxicillin online purchase

  121. can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada [url=http://zithromaxa.store/#]buy zithromax without presc[/url] zithromax price canada

  122. zithromax tablets [url=http://zithromaxa.store/#]buy zithromax 500mg online[/url] buy zithromax 1000 mg online