A court decision fit for a superhero

Lynne McTaggart

‘Truth, justice and the American way.’

That was the motto given to Superman, of all people, in comic books. It started out as just ‘truth and justice’ when the DC Comics’ superhero first appeared in 1938, but then the originators added the last bit about the ‘American way’ as an attempt to bolster public morale during the Second World War.

There it remained in Superman’s speaking balloons during the McCarthy years and beyond when Americans became paranoid about Communism and began to propagate the notion of American exceptionalism.

With the latest iteration of the superhero on film, the motto was updated last October to ‘truth, justice and a better tomorrow.’

But the original is the motto I grew up with, probably helped to form my moral compass, and had something to do with my becoming a journalist: the notion that justice and truth do prevail and that these ideals are somehow encapsulated in America with a constitution that embraced truth, justice and human rights for all.

In other words, I grew up believing that the good guys do, eventually, carry the day in order to preserve all those great fundamental rights.

These days, there isn’t much evidence of any of this in America or many other places, given all the lies and corruption in politics, industry and the media, the great economic divides, the unfairness and prejudice now built into many systems, and more.

But every so often truth and justice and all those lofty values we believe in do prevail, and not just in America.

That’s what just happened in Britain, when a court decision upheld the right of a lone UK doctor to speak up against the official line about Covid.

The plantiff’s name was Dr. Sam White, who practices in the Southeast. After qualifying as a conventional doctor, he ultimately turned to functional medicine to solve his own issues with Lyme disease and then decided to turn to integrative solutions to help his patients, too.

Dr. White’s record was impeccable until he started speaking out about Covid. He produced a YouTube video, questioning mask-wearing, lockdowns. and especially the efficacy and safety of the Covid vaccine.

National Health Service England responded by suspending him from a right to practice medicine on June 21 with the following statement:

‘Through a social media video, Dr White spread misinformation and inaccurate details about the Coronavirus and how it is diagnosed and treated, including saying the vaccine is a form of genetic manipulation which can cause serious illness and death and that he advised against wearing masks.

‘Dr White has potentially put patients at risk and diminished the public’s trust in the medical profession by disseminating misinformation and inaccurate details about the measures taken to tackle the Coronavirus pandemic.’

In the video, according to court documents, Dr. White claimed doctors and nurses were ‘having their hands tied behind their backs’ preventing them from using treatments that had been established as being effective both as prophylaxis from Covid19 infections and as treatments for it.’

During the hearing after which his license was revoked, Dr. White’s statement supporting his position ran to 106 paragraphs that addressed, point by point, the allegations contained in the summary of the YouTube video, eventually producing an  ‘extensive volume of literature and other sources’ to support his position.

Nevertheless, the UK’s General Medical Council suspended Dr. White’s license to practice medicine for 18 months, on the grounds that he was undermining public confidence in doctors, which would have a real impact on patient safety.

The Tribunal also imposed ongoing monitoring on Dr. White and  restricted him from posting or sharing his views about Covid on any social media platforms, even forcing him to remove previous posts.

The GMC quickly revoked that decision about his license a month later, but that wasn’t good enough for Dr. White.

He decided to sue them in the high court, arguing that the GMC had infringed upon his right to freedom of speech.

In hearing the case, the court did not examine the merits of Dr. White’s views – only his right to make them. Referring to Article 10 of the European Court of Human Rights, Justice Dove, who presided over the case, noted:

‘Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall include freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers.’

However, as Judge Dove pointed out, freedom of expression is a qualified right and as a ‘medical practitioner expressing opinions about medical matters his entitlement to freedom of expression is not absolute.’

Nevertheless, said the court, the GMC both ‘failed to afford sufficient respect to the claimant’s right . . . to freedom of expression or to ‘take account of the support for the claimant’s views to be found in the bodies of medical and scientific opinion which he had furnished to support the witness statement he lodged in the proceedings.’

Bottom line: Dr. Sam White won. He can put up his videos, he can speak out against the standard medical response to Covid, he can criticize the vaccine, he can put forward the other side of the story. And he is more than ready to do so.

As Judge Dove said, there are always qualifications about free speech. In the US, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, in making his decision on the Schenck case in 1919 said, that the test for limiting free speech is, essentially, context. Does it present ‘clear and present danger’ or cause national panic?

His famous analogy was that an individual is free to shout ‘fire’ when in front of a handful of people, but only in a crowded cinema as long as there is one – or the person mistakenly believes there is one.

That decision was later overturned in 1969 with Brandenberg v Ohio, which enlarged our First Amendment rights by concluding that free speech can only be curtailed if it is likely to incite imminent lawless action (like a riot).

So in these fevered Covid times, when anything criticizing government and medical policy is being removed on Facebook and elsewhere, Sam White finally fought over truth and justice about free speech – and prevailed.

His case, which demonstrated that there is sufficient scientific evidence countering every aspect of the official handling of Covid, may well provide precedent to others who are being deplatformed or silenced for criticizing the official line.

He showed us all that even during times of crisis, it is absolutely crucial for a democracy to allow dissenting views to be voiced and aired if we are going to arrive at truth or justice.

That, to my mind, is the very definition of a modern superhero.

Facebook Comments

We embed Facebook Comments plugin to allow you to leave comment at our website using your Facebook account. This plugin may collect your IP address, your web browser User Agent, store and retrieve cookies on your browser, embed additional tracking, and monitor your interaction with the commenting interface, including correlating your Facebook account with whatever action you take within the interface (such as “liking” someone’s comment, replying to other comments), if you are logged into Facebook. For more information about how this data may be used, please see Facebook’s data privacy policy: https://www.facebook.com/about/privacy/update

Lynne McTaggart

Lynne McTaggart is an award-winning journalist and the author of seven books, including the worldwide international bestsellers The Power of Eight, The Field, The Intention Experiment and The Bond, all considered seminal books of the New Science and now translated into some 30 languages.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

18 comments on “A court decision fit for a superhero”

  1. I have often wondered why so many people in the medical field continue to support the fabrication that is the Covid pandemic. The standard reply is that they fear for their jobs and have mortgages and families to support but, given the appalling levels of vaccine injury and deaths, surely it's incumbent on us all to follow the path of greater good and to speak the truth. There's a lot more involved here than just a so-called pandemic but if the sheep don't start waking up, we will soon be entering a future that bears closer comparison to Orwell's 1984.

  2. Thank you so much for bringing this to the public's attention!
    I never thought this would happen and that the truth would be supressed for years - Judge Dove has restored my faith in the judiciary.
    Great work, Lynne, in informing us all of this decision and explaining what had happened.

  3. Yes yes truth and justice can prevail. Hopefully we will soon see similar action occurring in the US, and the COVID inquisition will finally be exposed.

  4. Fantastic news and I believe Dr White is another hero in this awakening story. The tsunami of truth is about to be seen. The crowds now waking up just makes my soul sing. Every little bit we do really matters. Thank you Lynne

  5. Amen. It's so hard to wake people up, however. I try to alert people but only get ignored, patronized, or psychoanalyzed for my trouble. For example, I'm trying to get people to watch video of Senator Johnson's panel discussion on vaccine injuries/mandates, or Deborah Conrad's interview with Del Bigtree. People always come up with an excuse not to do so. I feel like I'm in a theater with smoke and flames everywhere, and yet everyone assumes I'm mentally ill when I yell "Fire!" It's incredibly frustrating.

  6. FYI to administrator... Tried to post a reply to Bruce Sawford, but it created a new comment.


  8. Excellent! Let's have thousands of such superheros! It could reverse our human future.
    With appreciation for your work

  9. Lynne said “ that even during times of crisis, it is absolutely crucial for a democracy to allow dissenting views to be voiced and aired if we are going to arrive at truth or justice”.
    Because of the amount of censorship and distorted truths the propaganda machines allow the public to see it is clear we are no longer ruled by democracy! Time to wake up as many as we can.
    Where can we find those 106 paragraphs - please.

  10. Thank you, Lynne, for sharing this encouraging court ruling in favor of Dr. Sam White .

    Our deepest appreciation to you, and to Dr. Sam White for STANDING for Truth and for the
    most basic Rights of all people.

    Those interested in these topics may want to look up the new
    Declaration of Universal Human Independence.

    It's time we reclaim our humanity and our rightful place in the universe.

  11. Closing in on 800,000 dead in US from Covid. I personally know of these: Husband and wife dead (both in their 80's but husband was still working). Another entire family father dead and mother might be gone soon, too. Daughter needed multple shots in her stomach because of blood clots. My neighbor's daughter died from Covid early in the pandemic before vaccines were available. Hospital workers on the front lines are crying because they are the ones struggling to keep people alive and have to contact the families after the patients they tried so hard to save, die.
    In the USA people are taking horse de-wormers and Magic Dirt (BOO). I am old enough to remember polio and how gratefull we all were once vaccines were available. A brother and sister in my neighborhood both got polio and nearly died. They survived but the sister had to wear a metal leg brace because of the paralysis.

  12. Hi all
    Its good to hear that a part of what I consider to be downright dodgy - The legal system in the UK - has come up with a correct decision regarding the outrageous threats from the National Health Service - good for the judge & the court
    I attended my local Optician last week who told me a similar story regarding threats made to him if he did not do as he was told - that they would take measures against him that would affect his business
    We are in very dangerous times and we need to stand up for our diminishing rights before we turn into a Nazi state -

    Carl Baxter

  13. Thank you Lynne, your article on Dr. Sam White is invaluable. Thumbs up for Dr. White who is like a beacon to his colleagues, other professionals and humanity. Dr. White lived up to M.L. King's quote that our lives begin to end when we keep silent about things that matter. We are blessed because there are individuals like you in our society, who shines light and gives hope for a better future.

  14. Dr Sam White is the absolute antithesis of someone who undermines trust in the medical profession. He is a hero because he didn't simply 'follow orders' but wanted to care for his patients based on objective evidence. He put principles before concern for himself and history will show that all doctors should have done the same.

Why wait any longer when you’ve already been waiting your entire life?

Sign up and receive FREE GIFTS including The Power of Eight® handbook and a special video from Lynne! 

Top usercarttagbubblemagnifiercrosschevron-down