CONNECT WITH LYNNE:

11 ways to speak with the ‘enemy’

On October 9th, 2020

I was talking with an American friend of mine the other day and she was complaining about another friend – a dear close friend – who does not share her choice of presidential candidate. Their discussion had become heated, and my friend was upset because her other friend continuously harangued her for maintaining her political point of view.

I’m hearing this from many friends of mine these days – their anger and upset, their futile attempts to change the minds of their ‘misguided’ friends and colleagues, and after watching the slanging match that was the first presidential debate, I got to thinking about how all of us have largely forgotten how to speak to people with a different point of view.

I’m not talking about people who are bigoted, racist or violent, but simply perfectly law-abiding, reasonable people who happen to want to vote for a different candidate or party than we do.

So here are some thoughts I have about dealing with political divides.

Avoiding differences

Currently most relationships and most interactions are forged from the erroneous idea that we have to be the same to get along and that differences between us are to be avoided at all costs.

In fact, conflict is considered so antithetical to the human experience that when others disagree with us, we conclude that they must be stupid or ill informed.

To justify this position, we find it necessary to debate them, demonize them, and announce their ignorance to the world. In our minds, conflict can be resolved only with I win, you lose.

While a debate is supposed to have a winner and a loser – and let’s hope that the next debate is conducted with both more content and more mutual respect – in ordinary discussions with friends, all of us could use some reminders about how to speak to the other.

I’ve found that the following suggestions allow you to make deep connections with anyone, even those who disagree with everything you stand for, and engage conflict in creative ways in order to produce greater shared understanding and possibility.

They also help you to promote closeness through the power of deep truth and candid disclosure rather than the strength of your arguments.

These techniques encourage the opposite of what you’ve learned in critical thinking or debating classes. You focus on what is positive, truthful, and wise about what others are saying, not the flaws in their arguments, and areas of common ground.

11 ways to speak to people who disagree

  1. Keep alert for “Us versus Them” thinking, language, and actions. As soon as you start generalizing about one race or ethnic group of people—whether Republicans, Muslims, or even bankers—you have defined a group as “them.” Expunge this kind of language from your vocabulary.
  2. Separate out gradations of belief. The idea that all the people who hold a certain view have the same exact position is a stereotype. As psychologist Dr Don Beck, creator of Spiral Dynamics system, once described, fine gradations of belief exist among people who appear to agree, and most of us outside of a belief system don’t appreciate the wide spectrum of beliefs held within any given position. Pro-choice advocates, for instance, have widely divergent views from each other, from those who believe that abortion is justified in all circumstances to those who believe abortion is justified only in cases of rape. Seek to identify these fine distinctions in beliefs or practices so that you do not miss a chance to find common ground.
  3. Seek out kernels of truth in any opposing position rather than the differences in views between the other person and yourself.
  4. Mentally swap roles with someone else. Imagine the issue from the polar opposite of your own position and offer as many solid arguments in favor of that position as you can. This helps you to take a larger perspective on the issue. By the same token, try to imagine someone else looking at your ideas. What do you think they see?
  5. Share honestly and reveal your backstory – why you have come to believe what you believe. Encourage the other to do the same.
  6. Experiment with a positive description of your differences. Instead of complaining, “Those atheist heathens don’t go to church,” think and say, “How interesting—atheists believe in a natural intelligence.”
  7. Listen activelywith your heart, mind, and soul. Listen to other things besides what the speaker is saying: how he describes things, what he emphasizes or where he places the most energy, how he holds his body, how he appears to feel.
  8. Uncover the hidden connections between you and other people, whether in your faith, your locality, your citizenship, your sex, or your local or national interests. Both Republicans and Democrats have many identical interests: a love of family, God, children, home, and country. All of us want to fix the economy, the roads, the government, the high price of gasoline, our educational system. Working out how to do so together affords us an opportunity to come together for a larger goal, at which point superficial differences diminish in importance.
  9. During differences, seek to change the space between you. Change the energy that flows between you by changing your tempo, your attitude, your facial expressions. Make your body language and unspoken communication transmit your desire to connect.
  10. Ask questions to clarify your understanding, not to score points, and use language that empowers the other. Instead of “What are you doing about X?,” which sounds accusatory (as if they aren’t doing enough), say, “What would you like to see done about X?”
  11. Finally, send that person some positive intention while he or she is telling you about their beliefs and position.

Try using these with people who are not like you and see what happens. You may well find that deep down you aren’t that different after all, and even if you are, there’s a way for both your truths to co-exist.

Comments

comments

7 responses to “11 ways to speak with the ‘enemy’”

  1. George S Mycroft says:

    OMG! With the way I was raised, these new (rediscovered?) ways of interacting and inter-relating are crucial for there to be any change, leading to a laying down of "weapons" and thus to cooperative peace and growth for us all. Mahalo, Lynne, for bringing them into conscious awareness. 😃 🙏🏼

  2. Nicolette Beerel says:

    Thank you, Lynne, very timely and much needed.
    I can relate to your friend. I almost never talk
    politics nor do I get angry quickly. Lately I have been infuriated by one particular friend who claims she has no opinion or feelings on the state of affairs here in the US. It’s not very honest. Respect and validation of the current environment are very important.

  3. Gilly says:

    Good words and good ideas about managing a debate. Thank you and I will try to keep them in my mind during this time when there is so much accusation going on.

  4. This post is wonderful Lynne. Thank you so much! I have two sisters, one very liberal and one very conservative. I finally decided that I would not participate in debates with them. Instead we all agreed to just kindly and respectfully SEARCH FOR TRUTH.Our sisterhood is more important than any politician. So far, so good a year down the road. Eliminated a lot of misinformation and emotion.

  5. edith says:

    Very good move! very important at this time

  6. Barbara says:

    Bless You for this beautiful offering!!! <3 <3 <3

  7. Barb says:

    Thank you, Lynne. Great article and ideas. I was on a call and the speaker talked about being curious about what the other person is saying and asking question to elicit what are their concerns that have them believe like they do. you are then getting to know the person, not just their belief.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Unit 9, Woodman Works, 204 Durnsford Rd
    London SW19 8DR.

    You can connect with Lynne at: info@lynnemctaggart.com 

    You can speak to Customer Services at:
    +44 (0)208 944 9555

    Privacy Policy
    shopping-carttwitter-squarefacebook-squareinstagram

    Lynne McTaggart